Martin Luther nailed 95 Theses to a church door in 1517, igniting a Reformation that recovered biblical truth from centuries of Roman Catholic corruption.
Five hundred years later, the church that bears his name is ordaining “pastors” with drag queens performing at the ceremony while a female “bishop” declares it looks like “King David dancing before the altar of God.”
If Luther could see what the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America has become, he’d burn his own writings, nail 95 MORE theses to their doors, and start the Reformation all over again.
I’m not talking about minor theological disagreements or matters of Christian liberty. This is full-blown, unrepentant, celebrate-it-on-social-media apostasy that would make Jezebel blush.
The ELCA—and their apostate Canadian cousins in the ELCIC (Evangelical Lutheran Church in Canada)—have kept the word “Evangelical” in their name while becoming the polar opposite of everything that word has meant for 500 years. It’s like calling yourself a vegetarian while running a slaughterhouse.
When “Evangelical” Became Code For “Everything Luther Fought Against”
Let’s start with the elephant in the sanctuary wearing a rainbow stole and preferred pronouns.
The word “Evangelical” comes from the Greek evangelion—the gospel, the good news. For centuries, it meant Bible-believing, gospel-preaching, Christ-exalting Christianity. Martin Luther was an evangelical. The Reformation was an evangelical movement. Evangelical meant you believed the Bible was God’s authoritative Word and that salvation comes through faith in Christ alone.
The ELCA kept “Evangelical” in their name. Somewhere between their founding in 1988 and today, they redefined it to mean “progressive,” “inclusive,” “justice-oriented,” and—most ironically—”anything but what evangelicals actually believe.”
They’re using Luther’s name to promote everything Luther spent his life fighting against.
The Sick Irony of False Labels
Here’s the twisted reality: Luther stood against the Roman Catholic Church because it had placed church tradition and papal authority OVER Scripture. Five hundred years later, the ELCA has placed cultural progressivism, social justice ideology, and LGBTQIA+ activism OVER Scripture.
Meet the new pope. Same as the old pope. Just wearing different vestments and marching in Pride parades.
The ELCA claims to be evangelical while:
- Denying biblical authority when it conflicts with culture
- Ordaining practicing homosexuals as pastors (since 2009)
- Blessing and performing same-sex marriages (mandatory since 2018)
- Ordaining transgender individuals (since 2012)
- Calling the Great Commission racist and fraudulent
- Featuring drag queens at ordinations
- Obsessing over “white supremacy” and “systemic racism” more than sin and salvation
That’s not evangelical. That’s apostasy with a Lutheran logo.
Luther’s Standard vs. The ELCA’s Surrender
Luther wrote, “Unless I am convinced by Scripture and plain reason… my conscience is captive to the Word of God. I cannot and I will not recant anything, for to go against conscience is neither right nor safe. Here I stand, I cannot do otherwise.”
The ELCA’s conscience is captive to the New York Times editorial board. Standing on shifting sand, they call it solid ground.
The Progression of Apostasy: How Did We Get Here?
The ELCA was formed in 1988 through a merger of three Lutheran bodies. From day one, they prioritized “diversity” and “inclusion” over doctrinal fidelity.
1970s-1980s: The predecessor bodies begin ordaining women (1970), setting the stage for abandoning biblical qualifications for church leadership.
1991: First ELCA conference on “racism and justice in the church.” Note: not “sin and salvation.” Not “gospel and truth.” Racism and justice—that tells you where their priorities were.
1993: Approved the social statement “Freed in Christ: Race, Ethnicity and Culture.” Sounds nice. It’s actually the beginning of making racial justice the central message instead of the gospel.
2009: The bombshell. The ELCA approved allowing congregations to ordain practicing homosexuals and bless same-sex relationships. This was the moment—the point of no return—when the ELCA officially chose culture over Scripture.
2012: Approved transgender ordination. Once you’ve abandoned biblical sexuality, why stop there?
2015-2018: Codified same-sex marriage, expanded rites to all dioceses, made it mandatory. Not just “allowed”—REQUIRED.
2016: Repudiated the “Doctrine of Discovery,” because apparently fighting 15th-century colonialism is more urgent than preaching the gospel in the 21st century.
2020s: Full-blown woke religion. Every ELCA document, every bishop’s statement, every churchwide assembly is obsessed with racism, white supremacy, LGBTQIA+ inclusion, and social justice. Meanwhile, membership is cratering and nobody’s getting saved.
This is what happens when you trade the gospel for grievance studies.
Women Pastors: The Gateway Drug to Full Apostasy
I’m going to mention this briefly because you can’t understand the ELCA’s trajectory without it, but we need to move to the more egregious stuff.
The ELCA ordains women as pastors and bishops. The Bible doesn’t. End of discussion.
“I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man, but to be in silence” (1 Timothy 2:12, NKJV).
“Let your women keep silent in the churches, for they are not permitted to speak; but they are to be submissive, as the law also says” (1 Corinthians 14:34, NKJV).
You can twist those verses into pretzels trying to make them say something else. The ELCA does. But Scripture is clear, and every church father, every Reformer, and Martin Luther himself understood what those passages meant.
Why This Matters For Everything Else
Here’s why this matters for our discussion: Once you decide you know better than Scripture on one issue, you’ll do it on every issue.
Women’s ordination was the gateway drug. Once the ELCA decided cultural pressure trumped biblical authority on that question, the floodgates opened. If Scripture is wrong about who can be a pastor, maybe it’s wrong about homosexuality. And if it’s wrong about that, maybe it’s wrong about transgender ideology. If it’s wrong about all of that, maybe the Great Commission itself is suspect.
That’s not a slippery slope. That’s a cliff, and the ELCA jumped off it decades ago.
Now let’s get to the really demonic stuff.
The Great Commission Is Racist? When Heresy Wears A Collar
Dawn Hutchings is a “pastor” (and yes, those scare quotes are doing a lot of work) at Holy Cross Lutheran Church in Newmarket, Ontario—part of the ELCIC, the Canadian branch of this apostate tree.
In a sermon that should have gotten her defrocked immediately, Hutchings claimed that the Great Commission—Matthew 28:18-20—is a fraudulent later addition to Scripture that’s responsible for racism and white supremacy.
Let that sink in for a second. The words of Jesus commissioning His disciples to make disciples of all nations? According to this woman, they’re fake. Added around 325 AD at the Council of Nicaea to support the Nicene Creed.
The Heretical Claim Dissected
Here’s what she actually said: “Could the so-called ‘great commission’ have been added to the gospel by the Christian community sometime around 325—to bring it into line with the brand spanking new Creed which you know as the Nicene Creed?”
This is not just bad scholarship. This is demonic deception.
Hutchings is parroting a debunked, fringe, liberal-critical theory that misuses quotes from Eusebius to claim the Trinitarian formula in Matthew 28:19 is inauthentic. Never mind that Eusebius himself quotes the FULL verse elsewhere. Never mind that EVERY manuscript we have includes it. Never mind that the church fathers quoted it centuries before Nicaea.
The Real Poison Behind The Lie
But here’s the real poison: She claims the Great Commission created “a legacy of colonization, land theft, and genocide” and is the root of “systemic racism and white supremacy.”
Translation: Evangelism is racist. Making disciples is colonialism. Preaching the gospel to the nations is white supremacy.
This is what the ELCA and ELCIC have become. They’re so consumed with “decolonizing” Christianity and fighting “systemic racism” that they’ve declared Jesus’ final command to His disciples—THE GREAT COMMISSION—illegitimate and evil.
What Scripture ACTUALLY Says
What does God’s Word actually say?
“Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age” (Matthew 28:19-20, NKJV).
Every manuscript. Every translation. Every church father. For 2,000 years, Christians have recognized this as the authentic words of Jesus.
Dawn Hutchings and her ELCIC colleagues know better than Jesus, apparently.
And the ELCIC hasn’t disciplined her. She hasn’t been removed. She’s still “in good standing.”
Because in the ELCA/ELCIC system, you can deny the authority of Christ and keep your collar. But if you dare say homosexuality is a sin? You’re the problem.
Drag Queens, Ordinations, And The Death Of Sacred Space
Now we get to the part that would make Luther pick up his inkwell and throw it at these demons all over again.
The ELCA has had multiple ordinations featuring drag queen performances.
Not at a nightclub. Not at a Pride parade. At ordination services. In church buildings. With bishops presiding.
Case Study 1: Dawn Bennett – The Drag Queen Nun Ordination
In 2018, Dawn Bennett—a self-described bisexual, queer woman—was ordained as a “pastor” in the ELCA in what might be the most sacrilegious ceremony in church history.
Here’s what happened:
- Ten drag queens dressed as nuns from “The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence” (an LGBT protest group that uses religious imagery to mock Christianity) sat in the sanctuary and cheered
- A “pagan wiccan priest who loves Jesus” served as one of the lecterns reading Scripture
- Her agnostic best friend read Scripture
- A gay pastor read Scripture
- Jennifer Knapp (former CCM artist turned LGBT activist) sang during communion
- Bennett wore rainbow sneakers she calls her “holy shoes” that remind her of “radical LGBTQ inclusion”
- Her vestments were covered in rainbow stripes and pins
Bishop Kevin Strickland of the Southeastern Synod presided and later said the ceremony was “a glimpse of what the kingdom of God is like.”
Let me be perfectly clear: That was not the kingdom of God. That was a portal to hell.
The Aftermath of Bennett’s Ordination
Months later, Bennett preached an Easter sermon—not about the resurrection of Jesus, but about affirming your “authentic gay/transgender self” while praying to “Holy Father, Holy Mother, Holy Parent” and thanking “Them” for “our collective queerness.”
This woman is still an ordained ELCA pastor in good standing.
Case Study 2: Megan Rohrer – The Trans Bishop
Megan Rohrer, a biological woman who identifies as a man, became the first openly transgender bishop in the ELCA in 2021.
Drag queens performed at Rohrer’s ordination.
On Rohrer’s first day as bishop, during a video call with ELCA leadership, Rohrer claims to have been “misgendered and ridiculed for featuring drag queens at his ordination.”
Think about that. The ELCA elected a transgender person as bishop. Drag queens performed at the ordination. And when someone on a video call supposedly “misgendered” this person, that was treated as the scandal—not the drag queens, not the transgender bishop, but the “misgendering.”
They’re policing pronouns while ordaining people who mock God’s creation order.
The Rohrer Scandal Explained
Rohrer resigned in 2022 amid racism allegations (yes, really—fired a Latino pastor on a significant feast day), then sued the ELCA for discrimination. The whole thing was a dumpster fire from start to finish.
But here’s what matters: The ELCA saw nothing wrong with a transgender bishop or drag queens at an ordination. Their only problem was the optics when it blew up publicly.
Case Study 3: The King David Comparison – Pure Blasphemy
Now we get to the quote that makes me want to flip tables.
An ELCA female “pastor” said this about the trans ordination with drag queens:
“18 months ago I was at an ordination of a trans man, and drag queens performed at the ordination. And we stood up and danced with drag queens…I thought to myself, this is what it looked like when King David danced in front of the altar of God.”
Read that again. Let it sink in how satanic that statement is.
She compared drag queens performing at a church ordination to King David dancing before the Ark of the Covenant.
What David Was Actually Doing
Let me remind you what David was actually doing:
“Then David danced before the LORD with all his might; and David was wearing a linen ephod. So David and all the house of Israel brought up the ark of the LORD with shouting and with the sound of the trumpet” (2 Samuel 6:14-15, NKJV).
David was worshiping God in humility and joy after bringing the Ark—representing God’s holy presence—back to Jerusalem. He was so consumed with reverence for God that he danced with abandon, despite his wife Michal despising him for it.
That’s worship. That’s holy reverence. That’s a man consumed with the glory of God.
The Blasphemous Comparison
Drag queens mocking gender, performing at a church service, celebrating sexual perversion—that’s not worship. That’s abomination. That’s rebellion. That’s demonic.
This woman took one of the most beautiful pictures of worship in the Old Testament and compared it to a drag show. That’s not just heresy. That’s blasphemy.
And the ELCA didn’t discipline her. Didn’t remove her. She’s still wearing the collar.
Because in the ELCA, you can blaspheme God and keep your job. You just can’t affirm biblical sexuality.
Trans Day of Remembrance: When The Church Celebrates What God Condemns
In November 2024, Advent Lutheran Church in Madison, Wisconsin—an ELCA congregation—hosted a “Transgender Day of Remembrance Interfaith Vigil.”
Not a gospel service. Not a revival. An interfaith vigil celebrating transgender ideology.
The church that claims to follow Luther is hosting interfaith services celebrating the denial of God’s creation.
God’s Design vs. Human Rebellion
“So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them” (Genesis 1:27, NKJV).
God created two sexes. Male and female. That’s not cultural. That’s not outdated. That’s creation order, written into our DNA, reflecting the image of God.
But the ELCA looks at God’s design and says, “Nah, gender is fluid. Biology is a social construct. We know better than the Creator.”
That’s not progressive. That’s insanity. And it’s leading people to hell.
The Destruction of a Generation
Transgender ideology is destroying lives. It’s sterilizing children. It’s mutilating bodies. It’s creating a generation of confused, medicated, mentally ill young people who’ve been lied to about reality itself.
And the ELCA’s response? Celebrate it. Host vigils for it. Ordain people who embrace it.
Jesus said, “Have you not read that He who made them at the beginning ‘made them male and female’?” (Matthew 19:4, NKJV).
The ELCA has read it. They just don’t believe it.
What Would Luther Say? (Spoiler: He’d Excommunicate All Of Them)
Martin Luther was not a soft man. He was not “winsome.” He was not afraid to call heresy what it was.
He called the pope the Antichrist. He told Erasmus his arguments had “the stench of Lucifer.” He wrote a treatise called “Against the Robbing and Murdering Hordes of Peasants.” The man did not mince words.
So what would Luther say about the ELCA?
On Biblical Authority
Luther’s entire Reformation was built on sola scriptura—Scripture alone. He famously said at the Diet of Worms: “Unless I am convinced by Scripture and plain reason… I cannot and I will not recant anything, for to go against conscience is neither right nor safe.”
The ELCA abandoned sola scriptura the moment they decided Scripture was wrong about sexuality.
Luther would say: “You are not the church. You are rebels against God’s Word, and you will answer to Him.”
On Sexuality and Marriage
Luther wrote extensively on marriage, sexuality, and gender. He was unambiguous: homosexual acts are sinful, marriage is between one man and one woman, and gender is fixed by God at creation.
In his commentary on Romans, Luther wrote about homosexuality as one of the clearest examples of human rebellion against God’s design.
The ELCA ordains practicing homosexuals and transgenders. Luther would excommunicate every single one.
On False Teachers
Luther wrote: “A preacher must be both soldier and shepherd. He must nourish, defend, and teach; he must have teeth in his mouth, and be able to bite and fight.”
About false teachers, he said: “Where God builds a church, the devil builds a chapel next door.”
The ELCA is the devil’s chapel wearing Luther’s name. And he would say so.
On Women Pastors
Luther was clear on this too: “God has not called women to preach or administer the sacraments.”
The ELCA has women bishops. Luther would be appalled.
On the Great Commission
Luther preached the Great Commission constantly. His entire theology was centered on justification by faith and spreading that gospel to the world.
The ELCA’s Canadian partner church calls the Great Commission racist and fraudulent. Luther would consider that demonic.
What Luther Would Do
If Martin Luther saw the ELCA today, here’s what he would do:
- Write 95 new theses calling out their apostasy point by point
- Nail them to every ELCA church door in America
- Publicly call them heretics and urge Christians to flee
- Start a new reformation to recover biblical truth from their corruption
- Burn their rainbow flags and false gospels
- Plead with God to raise up faithful pastors to replace them
Martin Luther would not recognize the ELCA as Christian. And neither should you.
The Numbers Don’t Lie: God Is Not Blessing Apostasy
Want to know what God thinks about churches that abandon His Word? Look at their membership.
The ELCA is dying. Not declining—dying.
- 1988 (founding): 5.2 million members
- 2010: 4.3 million members
- 2020: 3.3 million members
- 2023: Approximately 2.8 million members
They’ve lost nearly HALF their membership in 35 years.
Average Sunday attendance has fallen even more dramatically—from over 1 million in the 1990s to under 700,000 in 2023.
The Contrast With Faithful Churches
Churches are closing. Young people are leaving. And instead of repenting, the ELCA doubles down on the very heresies driving people away.
Meanwhile, conservative Lutheran bodies like the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (LCMS)—which holds to biblical authority and rejects women’s ordination and LGBT inclusion—have maintained their membership much better.
God blesses faithfulness. He judges apostasy. The ELCA is exhibit A.
God’s Warning to the Lukewarm
“I know your works, that you are neither cold nor hot. I could wish you were cold or hot. So then, because you are lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will vomit you out of My mouth” (Revelation 3:15-16, NKJV).
The ELCA isn’t even lukewarm. They’re ice cold, and they’re celebrating it.
The Sacred Cows That Need Slaughtering
Let’s gore some oxen:
Sacred Cow #1: “But My Family Has Been Lutheran For Generations”
I don’t care if your great-great-great-grandfather came over from Norway and helped build that stave church replica in Minnesota. Tradition doesn’t trump truth.
When a church abandons biblical Christianity, you leave. Period. Your loyalty is to Christ, not to a denomination.
Sacred Cow #2: “Not All ELCA Churches Are Like That”
Maybe your particular ELCA congregation hasn’t hosted drag queens yet. Maybe your pastor still preaches something resembling the gospel. But you’re in fellowship with churches that have, and your tithes support the denomination that ordains them.
You’re providing cover for heresy by staying. You’re giving money to apostasy. Leave.
Sacred Cow #3: “We Need To Stay And Reform From Within”
That ship sailed 35 years ago. The ELCA’s direction was set in 2009 when they approved homosexual ordination. Every year since then has been a march further into darkness.
You’re not reforming anything. You’re rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic while it sinks.
Sacred Cow #4: “At Least They’re Inclusive And Loving”
So is hell. It’s very inclusive—it accepts everyone who rejects Christ.
The ELCA’s “love” is sending people to eternal judgment by telling them their sin is fine.
Real love warns people about hell. Real love calls them to repentance. Real love preaches Christ crucified for sinners.
The ELCA’s “love” is a lie that damns souls.
What Scripture Actually Says
Let’s ground this in God’s Word, not human opinion:
On False Teachers: “Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits, whether they are of God; because many false prophets have gone out into the world” (1 John 4:1, NKJV).
On Sexual Immorality: “Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites… will inherit the kingdom of God” (1 Corinthians 6:9-10, NKJV).
On Gender: “So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them” (Genesis 1:27, NKJV).
On Judgment: “But I say to you that for every idle word men may speak, they will give account of it in the day of judgment” (Matthew 12:36, NKJV).
On Standing Firm: “Therefore, my beloved brethren, be steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord” (1 Corinthians 15:58, NKJV).
On Separation: “Come out from among them and be separate, says the Lord. Do not touch what is unclean, and I will receive you” (2 Corinthians 6:17, NKJV).
The Bottom Line: Leave Now, Warn Others, Speak Truth
The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America is not evangelical. It’s not Lutheran. And it’s barely Christian.
It’s apostasy wearing a cross.
From Luther to drag queens. From the gospel to grievance studies. From biblical authority to cultural captivity. From making disciples to declaring the Great Commission racist.
This is what happens when you trade Scripture for social justice.
Your Marching Orders
If you’re in an ELCA church, leave today. Not next month. Not after you find the perfect church. Not after the holidays. Today.
Find a church that believes the Bible, preaches Christ crucified and risen, and isn’t afraid to call sin what it is. Look at confessional Lutheran bodies like the LCMS or WELS. Or find a solid evangelical church that holds to biblical authority.
If you know someone in the ELCA, warn them. Love them enough to tell them the truth even if they hate you for it. Their eternal soul is at stake.
If you’re a pastor who’s been silent about mainline apostasy, speak up. Your congregation needs to know that not every church with “Lutheran” in the name follows Luther or Scripture.
Finding a Biblical Church
And if you’re looking for a church home, do your homework. Don’t assume a church is biblical just because it’s been around for 500 years or has Luther’s name on it. Test everything against Scripture.
The ELCA proves you can have all the tradition, all the liturgy, all the history in the world—and still be dead.
“Having a form of godliness but denying its power. And from such people turn away!” (2 Timothy 3:5, NKJV).
The Final Challenge
Martin Luther stood for truth when it cost him everything. He risked his life to recover the gospel from corruption.
The church that bears his name has betrayed everything he stood for.
Don’t be complicit in that betrayal through your silence, your attendance, or your tithes.
The stakes are too high. Eternity is too long. And God will not be mocked.