Average Bubba
Unfiltered

Raised on the Constitution. Seasoned in the South. Done biting my tongue.

Vol. II · No. 149 Saturday, November 14, 2026 Printed nowhere · Read everywhere

“HIS PEOPLE”

The leadership does not always get there first. By the time the elders schedule the meeting and the preacher clears his calendar and the deacons finish their quiet conversations in the parking lot, Sister Holy Karen has already rendered a verdict. Brother Do-Right has already consulted the bylaws of his own conscience and issued a ruling. The whisper network — which in a mid-sized American congregation can process information faster than any communication technology currently available — has already done its work. Nobody assigned them to this. Nobody elected them. They do not carry a title and they do not need one. They have occupied their pew since before you were born and they have watched people come and go for decades and they have developed a finely calibrated sense of who belongs and who does not, what kind of sin is forgivable and what kind leaves a stain, and exactly how long a person should have to demonstrate their rehabilitation before being readmitted to the full warmth of congregational fellowship. They are, as they would tell you themselves, sanctified. The word they mean is sanctimonious. The distance between those two words is the distance between what the church was supposed to be and what it became in too many zip codes across this country.

The leadership does not always get there first.

By the time the elders schedule the meeting and the preacher clears his calendar and the deacons finish their quiet conversations in the parking lot, Sister Holy Karen has already rendered a verdict. Brother Do-Right has already consulted the bylaws of his own conscience and issued a ruling. The whisper network — which in a mid-sized American congregation can process information faster than any communication technology currently available — has already done its work.

Nobody assigned them to this. Nobody elected them. They do not carry a title and they do not need one. They have occupied their pew since before you were born and they have watched people come and go for decades and they have developed a finely calibrated sense of who belongs and who does not, what kind of sin is forgivable and what kind leaves a stain, and exactly how long a person should have to demonstrate their rehabilitation before being readmitted to the full warmth of congregational fellowship.

They are, as they would tell you themselves, sanctified.

The word they mean is sanctimonious. The distance between those two words is the distance between what the church was supposed to be and what it became in too many zip codes across this country.

The Ground Operation

The machinery we have been talking about in this series does not run on leadership alone. Leadership provides the theological cover and the institutional authority. But the day-to-day operation — the temperature management, the social pressure, the thousand small signals that tell a person they are welcome or they are not — that runs on the rank and file.

Sister Holy Karen does not need a meeting. She has a look. You know the look. The one that takes you in from shoes to haircut and renders a judgment in under three seconds. The one that appears in the fellowship hall when you walk in with someone new, or when your name comes up in a conversation you were not in, or when you make a choice about your own life that falls outside the range of what is considered appropriate in this particular congregation in this particular county.

Brother Do-Right has a handshake that communicates conditional acceptance. He will shake your hand. He will say he is glad you are there. And then he will spend the rest of the service watching to see whether you stand at the right times and bow your head during the prayer and put something in the plate, and he will file his report internally and adjust his assessment accordingly.

These people are not monsters. That is the part that makes this complicated. Most of them genuinely believe they are doing the Lord’s work. They believe the community standards they enforce are biblical standards. They believe the temperature they maintain in the room is the appropriate temperature for a holy God’s holy people. They have been doing this so long in rooms that rewarded them for it that they have lost the ability to see it from outside.

But the people on the receiving end of it can see it just fine.

The One Who Stood Up

There is a specific moment this post needs to sit with.

A person stands up during the invitation. Maybe they have been sitting with something for weeks, months, years. Maybe they have been carrying a sin or a failure or a broken thing and the weight of it finally became greater than the fear of standing up in public and saying so. They walk to the front. They speak. They confess. They ask for prayer.

That is not a small thing. That is one of the most exposed, most vulnerable, most costly things a human being can do in front of other human beings. They have just handed the room the thing they were most afraid the room would see.

Now watch what happens.

Galatians 6:1 says — Brothers, if anyone is caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness. ESV. Restore. In a spirit of gentleness.

James 5:16 says — confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed. ESV. Pray for one another. That you may be healed.

That is what Scripture says happens next.

What actually happens in too many congregations is the whisper network activates before the closing prayer. The sideways glances start during the final song. The handshakes in the foyer carry new information now. People who did not know what your business was before you stood up now know what your business is, and some of them — not all of them, but enough of them — will carry that information forward indefinitely and deploy it at the moments it causes the most damage.

You asked for prayer and you got gossip dressed in concerned language. You asked to be restored and you got processed. You handed the room the most fragile thing you had and the room logged it in a file it will never close.

Some people only do that once.

The Elder Brother (Sister Too)

Jesus told the story in Luke 15. The younger son takes his inheritance early — which in that culture is roughly equivalent to telling his father he wishes he were dead — goes to a far country, wastes everything, ends up feeding pigs and eating their food. He comes to himself, as the text says. He goes home.

The father sees him coming from a long way off. He does not wait. He runs. He throws a robe on the boy’s shoulders and a ring on his finger and throws a party. — Luke 15:20-24, ESV.

Then there is the elder brother.

The elder brother has been outside working. He hears the music. He asks what is happening. Somebody tells him his brother came home and his father threw a party. And the elder brother will not go in. He is angry. He tells his father — I have been here the whole time, I have done everything right, you never threw me a party. And this son of yours — he does not say my brother, he says this son of yours — who wasted everything comes home and you celebrate.

Jesus put that elder brother in the story for a reason. He is not a villain in the traditional sense. He worked hard. He stayed. By every external measure he did what was right. But when the moment came to run down the road, he stood in the field with his arms crossed. When the moment came to go inside, he refused. When the moment came to say my brother, he said this son of yours.

Sister Holy Karen is the elder sister. Brother Do-Right is the elder brother. Every congregation in America has elder brothers and elder sisters and they are often the most visibly faithful people in the building and they are often the reason the prodigals do not come back a second time.

The father in the story does not rebuke the elder brother’s faithfulness. He says — son, you are always with me, and all that I have is yours — Luke 15:31, ESV. He honors the faithfulness. But he will not stop running toward the one who was lost. And if the elder brother cannot make peace with that, the elder brother has a problem that has nothing to do with the younger son’s sin.

The Ones Who Left God

This is the part that keeps me up at night.

Not the empty pews. Not the membership statistics. Not the declining percentage of Americans who identify as Christian. The ones who left God. Not the building — God. The ones who needed to find something real and found the temperature in the fellowship hall instead and concluded that was all there was.

I have talked to some of those people. You probably have too if you have lived long enough and paid attention. They are not angry most of the time. That is the thing. The anger burned off years ago. What is left is something quieter and harder — a settled conviction that the whole thing was performance, that the God those people represented was not worth knowing, that whatever was on offer inside those walls was not the thing they needed and they were better off without it.

Some of them are right that the God those people represented was not worth knowing. Because the God those people represented was not God. It was an institutional arrangement dressed in theological language, enforced by people who had confused their own preferences with holiness and their own comfort with righteousness.

The real God — the one who ran down the road, the one who sat at the well with the woman who had five husbands, the one who told the thief on the cross that today you will be with me in paradise — that God did not send Sister Holy Karen. He was not the one managing the temperature in the fellowship hall. He was not the one activating the whisper network.

His people were.

And somewhere in this country tonight there is a person who needed God and got His people instead and walked away from both of them at the same time and has not been back since.

That is not a statistic. That is a catastrophe.

What It Was Supposed To Look Like

The one another commands in the New Testament are not decorative. Bear one another’s burdens — Galatians 6:2, ESV. Love one another — John 13:34, ESV. Encourage one another — 1 Thessalonians 5:11, ESV. Confess your sins to one another — James 5:16, ESV. Restore one another in a spirit of gentleness.

That is not a program. It is not a small group curriculum. It is a description of what the ekklesia — the actual called-out people of God — is supposed to be when it is functioning the way it was designed to function. A place where the person who stands up and confesses gets prayed over, not filed away. Where the one who comes home gets a robe and a ring, not a probationary period. Where the temperature in the room says you are known and you are safe and you are not the worst thing you ever did.

That version exists. I want to be honest about that. There are congregations and house churches and small groups of people scattered across this country who are actually doing this, who have built something that looks more like Luke 15 than like the whisper network. They are not the ones this post is written to.

This post is written to the elder brothers.

Go inside. Your brother is home.

Truth Over Comfort. Always.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *