Average Bubba
Unfiltered

Raised on the Constitution. Seasoned in the South. Done biting my tongue.

Vol. II · No. 149 Saturday, November 14, 2026 Printed nowhere · Read everywhere

LUTHER’S GHOST IS BACK — AND HE’S WEARING A COLLAR

On October 31, 1517 a German monk named Martin Luther nailed ninety-five theses to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg and cracked the foundations of Western Christianity in a way that has never fully been repaired. He wasn't trying to destroy the Church. He was trying to reform it. He was tired of the corruption, the indulgences, the gap between what Rome preached and what Rome practiced. He wanted the institution to return to what it claimed to believe. Rome's answer was to excommunicate him. The result was the Protestant Reformation — the splintering of Western Christianity into dozens, then hundreds, then thousands of competing denominations. The Catholic Church responded with the Counter-Reformation. Tightened doctrine. Reasserted authority. Drew hard lines and dared anyone to cross them. For centuries it held. Until it didn't.

On October 31, 1517 a German monk named Martin Luther nailed ninety-five theses to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg and cracked the foundations of Western Christianity in a way that has never fully been repaired.

He wasn’t trying to destroy the Church. He was trying to reform it. He was tired of the corruption, the indulgences, the gap between what Rome preached and what Rome practiced. He wanted the institution to return to what it claimed to believe.

Rome’s answer was to excommunicate him.

The result was the Protestant Reformation — the splintering of Western Christianity into dozens, then hundreds, then thousands of competing denominations. The Catholic Church responded with the Counter-Reformation. Tightened doctrine. Reasserted authority. Drew hard lines and dared anyone to cross them.

For centuries it held.

Until it didn’t.


The Crack That Never Closed

Vatican II ran from 1962 to 1965. Convened by Pope John XXIII and continued under Paul VI, it was intended to modernize the Church’s relationship with the contemporary world. Some of what it produced was necessary and overdue. Some of what it produced was a door left deliberately ajar by the progressive wing of the institution — and they have been pushing it open ever since.

The language of Vatican II introduced concepts like collegiality, ecumenism, and the Church’s dialogue with the modern world. Legitimate theological ideas, handled carefully. But in the hands of the progressive faction they became a crowbar. A way to argue that doctrine isn’t fixed, that the Church must evolve, that the Holy Spirit is somehow always moving in the direction of whatever the culture finds acceptable this decade.

Luther’s ghost settled into the faculty lounges and the bishop’s conferences and got comfortable.


Germany — Where The Reformation Never Really Ended

Which brings us to the German Catholic Church and what it calls the Synodal Path.

Launched in 2019 in response to a catastrophic clerical abuse scandal, the Synodal Path was framed as a process of dialogue and reform. What it became was something else entirely — a formal institutional push to remake Catholic doctrine from the inside.

The German bishops have voted on blessing same-sex unions. They have pushed for the ordination of women as deacons. They have called for the elimination of mandatory celibacy for priests. They have proposed rewriting the Church’s teaching on sexual ethics from the ground up.

This is not a fringe movement. This is the organized Catholic hierarchy of the nation that gave the world Martin Luther formally voting to do what Luther accused Rome of failing to do five centuries ago — listen to the people instead of the doctrine.

Rome has pushed back. Inconsistently. Carefully. Without the kind of hard line that the situation arguably demands.

And here is why that matters beyond Germany’s borders.


The Road Already Traveled

The American mainline Protestant denominations took this same road. Every single one of them.

The Episcopal Church decided doctrine needed to meet culture halfway. Then culture moved and the Church moved with it. Then again. And again. Today the Episcopal Church is blessing same-sex marriages, ordaining openly gay bishops, and presiding over some of the most spectacular membership collapse in American religious history. Between 2003 and 2023 they lost roughly a third of their membership. Parishes closed. Dioceses went bankrupt fighting property disputes with congregations that left rather than follow.

The United Methodist Church spent decades trying to hold together a denomination divided over the same issues the German bishops are voting on right now. It finally split in 2024 — a formal denominational divorce that took years of litigation and cost hundreds of millions of dollars. The progressive wing kept the name. The orthodox wing walked out and started over.

The Presbyterian Church USA. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. The American Baptist Churches. All of them followed the same pattern. Chased relevance. Softened doctrine. Called it the Spirit moving. Watched the people leave anyway.

Because here is what none of them ever understood — and what the German bishops apparently haven’t figured out either.

People do not drive past three comfortable churches to get to a fourth comfortable church. They stay home. Or they find something that actually believes what it claims to believe.


The Warning For America

The American Catholic Church is already showing the same fault lines.

Mass attendance has been in steady decline for decades. Parishes are closing across the Northeast and Midwest at a pace that would have been unthinkable a generation ago. Catholic schools — once the backbone of urban education in this country — are shutting their doors in city after city. The scandals drove millions out and the institution’s response drove more.

And into that weakened, demoralized American Church comes the signal from Germany — that the solution to declining relevance is to become more relevant. To listen to the culture. To meet people where they are even if where they are is directly contradicted by two thousand years of doctrine.

Pope Leo XIV’s first moves will tell us a great deal about which direction Rome intends to go. He emerged from a conclave shaped almost entirely by Francis — a Pope who spent twelve years installing progressive allies in the College of Cardinals. The institutional momentum is not pointing toward hard lines and reasserted orthodoxy.

If Rome either endorses the German Synodal Path or simply fails to stop it — and failure to stop it is its own kind of endorsement — the American Catholic Church faces the same choice the Methodists faced twenty years ago.

We know how that ended.


What Luther Actually Wanted

Here is the final irony worth sitting with.

Martin Luther didn’t want to chase the culture. He wanted the Church to return to Scripture. To stop selling salvation and start preaching it. To close the gap between what the institution claimed and what it actually did.

What the German bishops are doing is almost precisely the opposite. They are not calling the Church back to Scripture. They are calling it forward to accommodate whatever the secular progressive consensus has decided is acceptable this decade.

Luther nailed his theses to a door because he thought the Church had drifted too far from what it claimed to believe.

Five centuries later his ghost is watching the German bishops vote on same-sex blessings and wondering how exactly this counted as an improvement.

When the Church chases the culture it doesn’t find the culture. It just loses itself.

And America’s empty Protestant pews are the proof.


If this landed — share it. If you want the next one in your inbox — sign up is in the sidebar—–

Truth Over Comfort. Always.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *