Average Bubba
Unfiltered

Raised on the Constitution. Seasoned in the South. Done biting my tongue.

Vol. II · No. 149 Saturday, November 14, 2026 Printed nowhere · Read everywhere

When Presbyterians Traded Westminster For Wokeness: The PCUSA’s March Into Heresy

The Presbyterian Church (USA) is dying. And before you start feeling sorry for them, understand this: they’re not victims of cultural shifts or demographic changes. They’re reaping exactly what they’ve sown—a bitter harvest of compromise, heresy, and outright rebellion against God’s Word.

When your “ministers” stand in pulpits declaring that Jesus was “a work in progress” who used “bigoted and offensive speech,” and your ordained clergy wear Planned Parenthood logos while bragging about their abortions from the pulpit, you’re not experiencing decline. You’re experiencing divine judgment.

And the numbers prove it.

The Death Spiral In Black And White

The PCUSA lost nearly 49,000 members in 2024, dropping to just over 1.045 million members. At their current rate of decline, they’ll drop below one million members by the end of 2025. Let that sink in—one of America’s oldest and most respected Protestant denominations is about to become a six-figure footnote in church history.

But here’s the kicker: they lost over half their membership since 2003, going from 2.4 million members to barely hanging on above a million today. Two-thirds of their congregations now have fewer than 100 members. In 2024, they planted exactly four new churches nationwide. Four. They used to plant nearly 30 per year.

This isn’t a trend. This is a collapse. And it’s not happening because people stopped caring about faith—the conservative Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) reported growth in 2024, adding over 7,000 members and 22 churches.

The difference? The PCA still believes the Bible.

When “Ministers” Mock The Master

Let me show you what passes for Presbyterian ministry in 2025. PCUSA pastor Amy Heinrich recently proclaimed from her pulpit that Jesus Christ—the eternal Son of God, the second person of the Trinity, God incarnate—was “a work in progress” who used “bigoted and offensive speech” when dealing with Gentiles.

Here’s the clip:

Read that again. A woman claiming to be a minister of the gospel just called Jesus Christ—who is “the same yesterday, today, and forever” (Hebrews 13:8, NKJV)—a work in progress. She accused the sinless Son of God of bigotry.

This isn’t a theological debate. This is blasphemy with a clerical collar.

Jesus wasn’t “learning” or “growing” or “evolving” in His understanding. He was and is God. “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God” (John 1:1, NKJV). The Word became flesh (John 1:14), but He never ceased being God. He was perfect, sinless, without blemish.

When Heinrich accuses Jesus of bigoted speech, she’s not being progressive—she’s calling God a sinner. And the PCUSA hasn’t defrocked her. They haven’t disciplined her. They’ve let her keep preaching her poison because she’s saying exactly what they believe: that modern progressive values are more enlightened than Jesus Himself.

The Abortion Gospel According To PCUSA

But if you think that’s as bad as it gets, let me introduce you to Rebecca Todd Peters—ordained PCUSA minister, professor of religious studies, member of the Planned Parenthood Clergy Advocacy Board, and perhaps the most brazen advocate for abortion you’ll ever encounter.

Peters didn’t just defend abortion. She celebrated it. She preached about it wearing a bright pink Planned Parenthood stole. She wrote a book called “Trust Women: A Progressive Christian Argument for Reproductive Justice.” And she stood in multiple pulpits declaring that she felt “God’s presence” during her two abortions and experienced “no guilt, no shame, no sin.”

Here’s a clip from one of her sermons:

Peters represents the PCUSA on the World Council of Churches. She’s been active in Presbyterian leadership for over 25 years. She’s not some fringe radical—she’s mainstream PCUSA.

In one sermon, Peters claimed that the Bible “says nothing about abortion”—a statement so absurd it would be laughable if it weren’t so damning. She argued that “prenates” (her made-up word for unborn babies) “are not yet human beings.” She accused Bible-believing Christians of having “toxic theology” for believing life begins at conception.

And in perhaps her most grotesque theological twist, Peters suggested that Eve’s choice to eat the forbidden fruit in the Garden of Eden was actually a great decision that Adam trusted her to make—and therefore we should “trust women” to decide to abort their babies.

Let me translate: Peters just used the Fall of mankind—the introduction of sin and death into the world—as a positive example for killing babies. She turned the moment of cosmic rebellion against God into a pro-choice talking point.

This is what the PCUSA ordains. This is what they platform. This is what they celebrate.

But Wait—Isn’t The PCUSA Pro-Choice Officially?

Oh yes. And they have been for decades.

The PCUSA declared in 1970 that abortion “should not be restricted by law.” In 1992, they adopted an official pro-choice position stating that abortion should not be limited by law in any circumstance. In 2006, their General Assembly reaffirmed that their Board of Pensions will pay for all legal abortions “without regard to the health or gestational age of the baby or the woman’s reason for choosing to abort her child.”

Read that last part again. The PCUSA will pay for abortions at any stage of pregnancy, for any reason. Third trimester? No problem. Viable baby? Doesn’t matter. Just don’t want to be pregnant? We’ll cover it.

After Roe v. Wade was overturned in 2022, the PCUSA doubled down, passing a resolution affirming “that women and pregnant people are full moral agents” with the capacity “to decide whether to continue or end any given pregnancy.”

They didn’t just accommodate abortion. They made it a sacrament of their false gospel.

The LGBTQIA+ Steamroller

Of course, abortion isn’t their only area of apostasy. The PCUSA has been on the cutting edge of sexual rebellion for years.

In 2011, they changed their Book of Order to allow ordination of openly LGBTQ individuals, removing the requirement that ministers live “in fidelity within the covenant of marriage between a man and a woman, or chastity in singleness.” That decision prompted about 300 congregations to leave and form the theologically conservative ECO: A Covenant Order of Evangelical Presbyterians.

By 2014, they changed the definition of marriage from “a man and a woman” to “two people.” In 1996, they became one of the first major denominations to ordain a transgender minister. And they’ve continued pushing, with recent overtures to add “sexual orientation and gender identity” to their non-discrimination policies in ways that would effectively bar anyone who holds to biblical sexuality from leadership.

The denomination that once gave us the Westminster Confession now celebrates what that same confession calls sin.

Where Are The Watchmen?

Here’s what grinds my gears: the silence from those who should know better.

First, you’ve got evangelical leaders who won’t call out mainline apostasy by name because it might hurt feelings or seem “uncharitable.” They’ll dance around it, talk about “theological differences,” maybe even express “concern”—but they won’t stand up and say what needs saying: The PCUSA has abandoned Christianity.

Second, you’ve got Christian colleges and seminaries that still maintain relationships with PCUSA institutions, still recognize their ordinations, still act like they’re part of the same family. They’re not. When you ordain people who call Jesus a bigot and celebrate abortion as God’s presence, you’re not Christian. You’re something else wearing a Christian costume.

Third—and this is the one that really burns—you’ve got the faithful remnant still in the PCUSA who keep saying, “We’re staying to be a witness” or “We’re working for reform from within.” Brothers and sisters, that ship has sailed, sunk, and been reclaimed by the progressive ocean. You’re not reforming anything. You’re providing cover for heresy by lending your presence to it.

The PCUSA went from ordaining women (1976) to ordaining practicing homosexuals (2011) to redefining marriage (2014) to celebrating transgenderism and abortion (2020s). At what point do you admit the trajectory is irreversible?

The Sacred Cows That Need Slaughtering

Let’s be brutally honest about some “respected” ideas that need to die:

Sacred Cow #1: “Historical Presbyterian Heritage”

Stop waving the banner of Calvin and Knox when your denomination ordains people who would make those reformers weep. The PCUSA doesn’t get to claim the Westminster Confession while violating every major doctrine it contains. Your heritage died when you decided progressive politics mattered more than biblical fidelity.

Sacred Cow #2: “Seminary Education Equals Qualification”

Rebecca Todd Peters has a Master of Divinity and a PhD in Christian Social Ethics from Union Theological Seminary. She’s educated, credentialed, and published. She’s also a heretic. Education without orthodoxy produces eloquent wolves. Stop assuming someone is qualified to lead just because they have degrees from liberal seminaries that stopped teaching biblical Christianity decades ago.

Sacred Cow #3: “Women Pastors Are Just As Faithful”

I’m going to say what needs saying: the push for women’s ordination in the PCUSA wasn’t about spiritual gifts or calling. It was the opening salvo in a decades-long campaign to remake Christianity in the image of progressive politics. And Peters and Heinrich are the fruit of that tree. When you violate clear biblical teaching in one area, you establish the precedent that cultural pressure can override Scripture. Everything else follows.

Sacred Cow #4: “At Least They Still Talk About Jesus”

Heinrich calls Jesus a bigot. Peters uses Him as a prop for abortion rights. The PCUSA “Jesus” is a social justice warrior who affirms everyone, judges no one, and exists to validate whatever progressive cause is trending. That’s not the Jesus of Scripture. That’s an idol with a familiar name. Stop pretending denominations that gut the gospel still worship the same God.

Sacred Cow #5: “Slow Decline Is Just Natural”

No. This isn’t demographics. This isn’t cultural shifts. This is the judgment of God on a denomination that has spit in His face. When you lose half your members in two decades while conservative Presbyterian denominations grow, that’s not a trend—that’s a verdict. “The Lord will not hold him guiltless who takes His name in vain” (Exodus 20:7, NKJV).

What The Bible Actually Says

Since the PCUSA has decided Scripture is optional, let’s remind ourselves what God actually says:

On False Teachers: “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravenous wolves. You will know them by their fruits” (Matthew 7:15-16, NKJV). The fruit of PCUSA leadership is death—spiritual and literal.

On Abortion: “You shall not murder” (Exodus 20:13, NKJV). “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you” (Jeremiah 1:5, NKJV). God doesn’t see a “prenate”—He sees a person. And killing that person is murder, no matter how many degrees you have or how progressive your theology.

On Sexual Sin: “Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites… will inherit the kingdom of God” (1 Corinthians 6:9-10, NKJV). Paul didn’t stutter. God didn’t leave room for reinterpretation.

On Christ’s Perfection: “For we do not have a High Priest who cannot sympathize with our weaknesses, but was in all points tempted as we are, yet without sin” (Hebrews 4:15, NKJV). Jesus wasn’t a work in progress. He was and is perfect God and perfect man.

On Judgment: “For the time has come for judgment to begin at the house of God; and if it begins with us first, what will be the end of those who do not obey the gospel of God?” (1 Peter 4:17, NKJV). The PCUSA’s collapse isn’t random—it’s righteous judgment.

The Bottom Line

The Presbyterian Church (USA) isn’t experiencing a rough patch or a temporary decline. They’re dying because they killed themselves. They traded the Westminster Confession for Planned Parenthood talking points. They exchanged biblical authority for progressive credentials. They chose cultural approval over divine truth.

And they’re not alone.

The Episcopal Church we exposed yesterday? Same story, different vestments. The United Methodist Church? Hold that thought—because in our next post, we’re taking a long, hard look at the UMC’s equally spectacular implosion. Spoiler alert: they’ve got their own special brand of apostasy, and it’s just as damning.

Here’s the pattern you need to see: every mainline Protestant denomination that has embraced progressive theology is dying. Every. Single. One. Meanwhile, denominations that hold to biblical authority—even when it’s unpopular, even when it costs them—are growing.

That’s not a coincidence. That’s cause and effect.

So here’s your action plan:

If you’re in a PCUSA church, get out. Today. Not when it’s convenient. Not after you find the “perfect” replacement. Leave now and find believers who actually believe the Bible. Your spiritual life—and possibly your eternal soul—is at stake.

If you know someone in the PCUSA, warn them. Show them this article. Send them Peters’ sermons. Let them see Heinrich’s blasphemy. Love them enough to tell them the truth even when it’s uncomfortable. “He who turns a sinner from the error of his way will save a soul from death” (James 5:20, NKJV).

If you’re a pastor watching mainline denominations collapse, speak up. Stop being diplomatic about apostasy. Call it what it is. Warn your people that not every church with a steeple is preaching Christ. Your silence is complicity.

If you’re looking for a church, do your homework. Don’t assume anything based on denomination, history, or reputation. Ask hard questions:

  • Do they believe the Bible is the inspired, inerrant, authoritative Word of God?
  • Do they preach sin as rebellion against a holy God requiring repentance?
  • Do they teach that Jesus Christ is the only way to salvation?
  • Do they uphold biblical standards for sexuality and marriage?
  • Do they call abortion what it is—murder?

If they waffle on any of these, keep looking.

Study the Word to see how the first-century church functioned. Find a genuine, authentic fellowship of like-minded believers who are committed to Scripture as written, not as culture wishes it were written. Those churches exist—and they’re often the ones the culture hates most.

The PCUSA proves that you can have every institutional advantage—history, buildings, endowments, educated clergy, cultural respectability—and still be spiritually dead. “Having a form of godliness but denying its power” (2 Timothy 3:5, NKJV).

Don’t be fooled by the form. Test the content. Demand biblical fidelity. And when you find a denomination that ordains people who call Jesus a bigot and celebrate abortion as blessing, run.

The stakes are eternal. The Word is clear. And the PCUSA’s collapse is a warning we’d better heed before it’s too late.

Coming Next: The United Methodist Church—When “Unity” Means Compromise And Everybody Loses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *