Last post we talked about the disqualified. The roster of people God chose that the institutional approval process would have shown the door — David, Paul, Peter, Rahab, the woman at the well, the full company of them. We established the pattern. God does not call the qualified. He qualifies the called.
Today we talk about the machinery that runs the approval process. What it is, what it actually does, and what it has cost the American church in the aggregate. Because this is not a local problem and it is not a new problem and at this point there are receipts.
What The Machinery Actually Does
Here is the thing about judgment. It is useful.
Not in the way the people doing it intend. Not as accountability, not as discernment, not as shepherding the flock. It is useful as a shield. You do not have to look too closely at your own inventory when you are busy auditing someone else’s. You do not have to sit with your own sin when there is a more visible sinner in the room to point at.
Jesus named this in Matthew 7. Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, he said, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye — Matthew 7:3, ESV. He was not speaking gently. He was describing a specific mechanism, and He was describing it with accuracy because He had watched it operate in real time among real religious people who were absolutely convinced of their own clarity of vision.
The machinery does not run on malice, mostly. It runs on fear. Fear of what it means if the disqualified get to stay. Fear of what the exceptions say about the rules. Fear of what happens to the arrangement if the arrangement gets questioned. And because fear dressed in religious language is harder to identify than fear dressed in plain clothes, it circulates through congregations for decades without anyone naming it for what it is.
It protects the people it was built to protect. It processes everyone else.
The Chair
I am not writing this from a distance.
I have sat in the chair the machinery builds for certain people. I know what the temperature in a room feels like when someone has decided your past disqualifies your present. I know how that works and what it costs and what it produces in a person over time.
I am also not a victim. I want to be clear about that. What happened, happened. What I did with it afterward was my responsibility. God stayed in the room when certain people made clear they preferred I leave it, and that is the only accounting that has ever mattered to me.
But I know the chair. And I know there are people reading this right now who know it too. Some of them are still sitting in it. Some of them walked out the door and have not been back inside a church building since. And some of them — more than the people who built the machinery would like to admit — left the building and never lost their faith at all. They just stopped pretending the building and the faith were the same thing.
The Receipts
Here is what the numbers say.
Pew Research Center’s 2023-2024 Religious Landscape Study surveyed nearly 37,000 American adults. What they found is not subtle. Christian identification in America has dropped from 78 percent in 2007 to 62 percent in 2024. The religiously unaffiliated — people who call themselves atheist, agnostic, or nothing in particular — now represent 29 percent of the country. Mainline Protestant denominations have fallen from 18 percent of American adults to 11 percent in that same period.
Thirty-five percent of American adults have walked away from the religion they were raised in.
When Pew asked the people who left and now claim no religion why they left, the answers were not primarily about theology. Half of them cited not liking religious organizations. Nearly half cited not trusting religious leaders. Those are not people who lost their faith in God. Those are people who lost their faith in the institution. There is a difference, and the institution has not been particularly honest about which one it is.
The machinery has been doing this work for a long time. Pew just put numbers on it.
What They Did Not Lose
The exits are real. But here is what I want to say to the people who made them.
You did not leave God when you left the building. God was not installed in the building. He was not created by the arrangement and He did not leave with it when you did. The fire in your bones, if you still feel it — and some of you do, I know because I hear from you — that is not a residue of a dead faith. That is the thing that was real when everything else turned out to be furniture.
Paul wrote to the church in Galatia about people who had gotten turned around by a certain kind of religious machinery — the version that added requirements to grace and used compliance as a sorting mechanism. For freedom Christ has set us free, he said. Stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery — Galatians 5:1, ESV.
The machinery is a yoke. It was always a yoke. The people who built it will tell you it is a standard. There is a word for that and the word is not standard.
If the exits are going to stop — and they should stop, because people walking out of the American church in those numbers is a catastrophe regardless of what produced it — the institution is going to have to look at the machinery and decide what it is willing to do about it. Not what it is willing to say about it in a sermon series with a catchy title. What it is willing to do.
That is a harder conversation than most of these buildings are currently set up to have.
Truth Over Comfort. Always.